Wednesday, February 20, 2013

The Role of the United States in the Israeli-Palestinian Settlement Dispute


Israeli Settlements in Palestine

As of the end of last month, around 520,000 Israelis live in settlements on Palestinian soil. 
The Israeli settlement of Modi'in Illit


Additionally, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has reaffirmed that more settlements would be built. This statement was delivered soon after Palestinians protesting the planned construction were forcibly evicted by Israeli soldiers. 





These settlements also have opposition abroad, such as the recent UN investigation that declared the building of homes for Israelis in Palestine illegal, and suggested that it could be considered a war crime. Despite the generally negative reaction to Israel's recent actions, the United States remains a stalwart ally of Israel, a stance that I feel is increasingly illogical considering Israel's expansionist, uncooperative actions.

A History of  US Support


Israel, one of very few US allies and democratic nations in the Middle East, has long benefited from US support, both militarily and economically. As a result, Israel has one of the most powerful and technologically advanced militaries in the Middle East. However, rather than defend itself from neighbors as Israel once had to, it has the power to build more and more settlements in Palestine while Palestinians can do nothing but protest and request help from the international community. But as long as the US firmly backs Israel, there is, in reality, very little other nations can or will do in response to these settlements.

Policy Change


It now seems hypocritical of the US to strongly support Israel as long as they continue expanding into Palestinian territory. I would argue that the US should join the rest of the world in censuring Israel and supporting Palestinian statehood. Despite the fact that in this nation, being “hard on Israel” is generally seen as negative, I think that unless Israel ceases violating international law, it is exactly the stance the US must take. Although little military action has been involved, Israel has still taken over land that was, as decided by the UN many decades ago, part of Palestine. From some other nation, this type of behavior would be (and has been) seen as reason to go to war, and while I do not suggest military intervention, I feel that the US is obligated as an active member of the international community to take a much sterner approach to relations with Israel as long as the Israeli government claims Palestinian land as its own.

2 comments:

  1. I don't really know a whole lot about this, but I feel like the United States' ally with Israel is both good and bad. It's good because if the US isn't going to defend and help Israel then who is? And besides, like mentioned in the blog, this ally with Israel could possibly be beneficial to the US both economically and militarily. And I mean, it never hurts to have extra help in these areas.
    BUT our ally with Israel is bad too because it is creating enemies; the countries that are upset with Israel right now are or are going to be upset with the US as well. And this could start another branch of war that we would be dragged into.
    The US is definitely in risky and controversial business because of the ally they hold with Israel.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One of the problems with the alliance with Israel is that the U.S. condemns allies of nations that are seeking to develop nuclear weapons and show signs of hostility, when not only has Israel become fairly aggressive of late, but they have had nuclear weapons for some time. And while Israel might have needed aid to defend itself at one point, now it seems that they use it to threaten other nations and absorb Palestinian land. So whether the alliance is beneficial to the U.S. or not, I think at this point, that the U.S. is being hypocritical by not speaking out against Israel's actions. As long as the U.S. tries to act as a world policeman, it seems wrong that we would support an aggressive nation.

      Delete